Media Standards Trust Leveson Coverage Analysis


Media Standards Trust

09.05.13

Posted by Media Standards Trust

 

Read the report here: MST Leveson Content Analysis Report pdf (.pdf)

The datasets used in the report, and a Q&A on our research, can be found here

 

The Media Standards Trust today publishes a report ‘Analysis: Press Coverage of Leveson Part 1: The Inquiry’, the first comprehensive review of the UK Press’ coverage of the Leveson Inquiry.

  1. Over 2,000 articles and over one million words were published on the Inquiry between July 2011 and November 2012 – 73% during the period of oral hearings
  2. One viewpoint dominated evaluative coverage of the Inquiry. Of those articles that expressed a view, 76% presented one perspective;
  3. That viewpoint was overwhelmingly negative. Only 18% of articles that expressed or contained a view were positive (6% contained both positive and negative views). Negative coverage increased substantially in the 100 days before publication of the Leveson Report
  4. Reporting on proposed regulatory outcomes was virtually non-existent. Of the 3% of articles that dealt substantively with plans for a new system of press regulation, 9 out of 10 were about the newspaper industry’s own plan.

Other key findings were:

  • Negative coverage usually framed the Inquiry as a potential threat to press freedom. 280 stories (64%) of those with evaluative coverage) contained descriptions of the ‘threats’ posed by press regulation. In contrast, there were 103 positive references to the Inquiry in all newspapers across the whole period of study
  • In the 100 days prior to the publication of the report, newspaper leader articles on the Inquiry nearly all contained negative references to the Inquiry or its outcomes. Of 28 leaders in all papers published between 20th August and 27th November 2012, 23 contained only negative viewpoints on the Inquiry. Two contained no evaluative statements at all, while three contained both positive and negative viewpoints. None were purely positive.

The report is published alongside the datasets generated by the project (available here: http://mediastandardstrust.org/mst-news/mst-leveson-coverage-analysis-data-and-qa/), and the MST invites the public to analyse the data first-hand for their own research, or to comment on the content of the report.

Media Standards Trust Research Fellow and author of the report Dr. Gordon Neil Ramsay said: “It is startling to see the lack of diversity of viewpoints in the Leveson coverage, not just in opinion pieces, but also from sources in news articles. It is also striking that, while expressing a clear view of their own, few papers gave the public the information necessary to make their own minds up about the future system of regulation”.

To discuss the results or for further comment please contact Dr. Gordon Neil Ramsay at

+44 (0)20 7727 5252 or gordon.ramsay@mediastandardstrust.org

(update: a correction was made to Table 13 at 12.40 on 9th May 2013)

  • http://twitter.com/DopeyJim Jim Hutchon

    This reinforces the impression that the press megaphone was overheating as the Inquiry reached its climax. But I do feel the public are not really being taken in (having heard it all before). I think, as usual, the press has overplayed its hand. I certainly hope so as it is the clearest indication that the press is not concerned with the public interest – only with its self-perpetuating bullying.

Latest news and blogs

MST Response to PCC Defence of IPSO

27.03.14 Media Standards Trust

  The Media Standards Trust has submitted a response to the Culture, Media and Sport...

More

Journalisted Weekly

Pistorius bail, Moody's downgrade and Child poverty

26.02.13 Pistorius bail, Moody's downgrade and Child poverty

Pistorius bail covered most

More

Orwell Prize newsletter

Orwell Prize 2014 Launch Debate: 21st October

18.09.13 Orwell Prize 2014 Launch Debate: 21st October

The Orwell Prize 2014 Launch Debate will be at the Frontline Club on October 21st. Book Here

More

PCC Watch

PCC Watch on hold

4.05.11 PCC Watch

PCC Watch is on hold until after the publication of the Leveson report

More

Events